Like most English teachers, I got into this line of work because I love reading. Books have always had the power to put me in other people’s shoes, to walk me into places I might never know and probably, most profoundly, to walk me into my own thinking in a way that gives me clarity. Reading has been a constant in every chapter of my life and if I’m being honest, books are the one and only material possession that I have refused to part with, move after move after move.
So, of course, I want my students to love reading too — and to be able to dive confidently into a new book with the deep belief that it has the power to teach them something new, transport them somewhere they’ve never been, and just maybe, move them in ways they never thought possible.
The problem, of course, is that most high school kids do not love reading. And, as a result, an increasing number are graduating from high school without the reading skills they need to be successful in the world. New research confirms this, with recent data from the 2025 National Assessment of Education Progress revealing significant dips in reading proficiency among high school seniors — the lowest average score, in fact, since the test’s inception in 1992.
Now, I could spend this entire article interrogating the validity of standardized tests like this — how they correlate closely with socioeconomic and racial bias; how they narrow the focus of instruction by encouraging educators and institutions to design instruction around test success; or how they rarely capture important learning outcomes like critical thinking and creativity — but the truth is, this test has captured something here, something that mirrors my own experience in the classroom: By and large, high school kids do not like reading and as a result, they’re not very good at it.
Why this is so has been bandied about for the last couple of years, but it doesn’t take a rocket scientist to understand the simple fact that teenagers have a million flashier and more compelling places to put their attention. And, let’s be clear, those spaces are not neutral sites of information, nor are their purveyors particularly interested in our children’s education or well-being. They are, instead, commercial spaces owned by big private companies devoted entirely to using their unregulated power and vast technological and scientific resources to capture and hold the attention of our children. If this sounds scary and diabolical, it might be because it is.
The good news — some very timely research has revealed just how damaging this is to children’s ability to learn and this research has informed some significant policy changes across the country. To date, 26 states — including the one I teach in — have implemented strict laws that require schools to ban cell phones and other devices during school hours. What this means is that teachers in those states have 6 whole hours during the school day when our student’s attention belongs solely to us.
In my 12th grade English classroom, I’ve been spending some of that time and attention trying to help my students become more confident and proficient readers. Some of the things that seem to be working:
Reading aloud. I lead students into a new book by reading it aloud in class, modeling my own prosody and stopping frequently to identify literary elements, explore unfamiliar words and track plot, characters and emerging themes. Soon, students volunteer to read and I always reward their efforts with lavish praise and encouragement. I also use differentiated questioning to get students with varying degrees of reading proficiency involved in the conversation. Because research suggests a strong correlation between reading fluency and comprehension, my goal is to help every student in the classroom feel confident enough to read aloud and to respond to questions about our text.
Cultivating Confidence. When students feel like they understand a text — and just as importantly — feel like they have the skills to read and understand texts well, they become willing to read more and tend to do so with increased enthusiasm, confidence and proficiency. Research around self-efficacy and reading proficiency supports this claim, as does a common trope informed by the idea of “The Matthew Effect” which basically suggests that early success in reading leads kids to read more, which in turn leads to greater skill development. Conversely, early difficulties in reading lead students to read less, which results in a widening gap in literacy skills over time. The bottom line — finding pleasure and success in reading translates to more reading and greater proficiency.
Building reading stamina gradually. As students become more engaged in a book and more confident, I give them brief independent reading assignments to be done either in class or for homework. Our conversation the next day reveals who did or did not do the reading and I find, almost without exception, that students will do the independent reading with integrity if they are engaged in the classroom conversation and feel some responsibility to the class community. As the year goes on and students feel more confident and successful, I increase the length and complexity of the assignments. By the second half of the year, I am able to assign scholarly articles about the texts we are reading and students, by and large, do the work necessary to understand and annotate these college-level articles.
Teaching students to annotate. There are many ways to do this, but I have found Cornell Notes to be uniquely suited for the task. (See notes at the end for more information about this tool.) I adapt the format slightly, but the idea is the same, with students moving from big picture questions and ideas (cues) to more specific details (notes) and finally, to a brief synopsis of the chapter (summary). With my 12th grade students, I don’t require them to take Cornell Notes, but I often announce that if they do have notes (Cornell or some other format) they can use them on any quiz, test or essay on the book. As a result, most of my students opt to take Cornell Notes when they’re reading independently and many of my students have told me they intend to use this strategy in college.
Creating meaningful assessments. Deep engagement with our reading requires student behaviors that are not easily assessed: reflection, curiosity, patience, sustained attention, a commitment to rereading, consideration of multiple possibilities, and a myriad of other intangible elements. Creating assessments that go beyond recall, memorization and superficial analysis is challenging, but necessary work.
Choosing texts intentionally. Although public school teachers do not always have the freedom to choose every text we teach, we do enjoy some agency over text selection and I believe that we have a shared responsibility to choose texts that not only reflect the diverse identity of our students, but also challenge problematic social and cultural injustices. To this end, I actively seek out contemporary literary titles that are interesting to my students and in which they can see themselves. I also find that foregrounding the social and cultural context of a book and the inherently subversive nature of disrupting the traditional literary canon can be a very compelling reason for students to want to read a book.
Coaching students. If reading is a muscle that requires both strength and stamina, I try to coach my students how to train. Helping students to understand the critical importance of deep reading and to know that they can actually train to become stronger readers is critical. When students are reminded that they have read five or six books over the course of a school year, there is a sense of pride and accomplishment that helps to build the confidence they need to continue on this path. Getting in shape is hard work, but there is no greater motivator than seeing progress. By emphasizing to my students that they are quite literally changing their brains every time they deeply engage with a text, I am teaching them that progress is exponential and that each encounter with a book will be deeper and more meaningful than the last.
Being the reader I want my students to be. Modeling my love of reading and my passion for language is paramount. I read aloud with my students, wonder aloud with my students, stop to look up things I’m not sure about and invite them to do the same. I sometimes stop at a powerful sentence, just to marvel at the beauty of the language. I cry openly at the sad parts, laugh when it’s funny, and check in with my students frequently. When we are in a book together, it is like we are on a journey and I am vigilant about making sure that we don’t leave anyone behind.
References
Recent Trends in Student Reading Skills: https://www.cnn.com/2025/09/09/us/student-testing-scores-drop-hnk
Oral Reading and Comprehension: https://ila.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1002/JAAL.00103
Self-Efficacy and Reading Proficiency: https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/02702711.2020.1783146
The Matthew Effect: https://ignite-reading.com/insights/science-of-reading-research-history/#mattheweffect
How to Build Reading Stamina: https://www.edweek.org/teaching-learning/how-to-build-students-reading-stamina/2024/01
Cornell Notes: https://lsc.cornell.edu/how-to-study/taking-notes/cornell-note-taking-system/
Additional Reading About Reading
Book Love: Developing Depth, Stamina, and Passion in Adolescent Readers (Penny Kittle)
The Book Whisperer: Awakening the Inner Reader in Every Child (Donalyn Miller)
From Striving to Thriving: How to Grow Confident, Capable Readers (Stephanie Harvey and Annie Ward)
Game Changer! Book Access for All Kids (Donalyn Miller and Colby Sharp)
No More Independent Reading Without Support (Debbie Miller and Barbara Moss)
Readicide: How Schools Are Killing Reading and What You Can Do About It (Kelly Gallagher)
The Reading Zone: How to Help Kids Become Skilled, Passionate, Habitual, Critical Readers, 2nd ed. (Nancie Atwell and Anne Atwell Merkel)